Learn · N2 · Short reading

静かな同僚の意見

会議でほとんど話さない同僚を、仕事への関心が薄い人だと思っていた。ところが、資料について後で感想を聞くと、会議では出なかった鋭い指摘が次々に返ってきた。大勢の前では考えをまとめる時間が足りないのだという。発言の少なさだけで意欲を判断すれば、大切な意見が届かない恐れがある。それ以来、私は会議の前に論点を知らせ、書面でも意見を受け取るようにしている。話す速さにかかわらず、考えを示せる場を作りたい。
English study notes

Learning objective

Identify why the writer now offers more than one way to contribute opinions.

Reading help

The writer once assumed that a quiet colleague lacked interest. A later conversation revealed insightful points; the colleague needed more time to organize thoughts in front of a group. The writer now shares discussion points in advance and also accepts written opinions so that speaking speed does not decide whose ideas are heard.

Glossary

鋭い(するどい)
Perceptive or insightful when describing an observation.
意欲(いよく)
Willingness or motivation to take part in an activity.
論点(ろんてん)
A particular point or issue to be discussed.
書面(しょめん)
A written form of communication.

After reading

- The writer initially misjudged a quiet colleague's interest. - A later conversation revealed useful points missing from the meeting. - Advance topics and written responses now offer other ways to contribute.

Exam focus & common mistakes

• Treat the opening belief as something corrected by the experience that follows. Choosing an answer based only on the first sentence would preserve the mistake the writer has abandoned. • A useful contribution need not arrive immediately in a group discussion. The final sentence widens access to expression; it does not require the colleague to become a faster speaker.

Exam practice and explanations

Exam practice

筆者は、会議であまり話さない人に対してどうするのがよいと考えているか。

Show answer

Answer: 4

  1. Meaning: Their participation in important meetings should be reduced until their interest in work increases. In this question: Wrong — The later conversation produced 「会議では出なかった鋭い指摘が次々に返ってきた」, showing that quietness did not mean a lack of useful engagement requiring exclusion.
  2. Meaning: They should be trained to state opinions immediately on the spot, and written opinions should not be accepted. In this question: Wrong — The writer now follows 「会議の前に論点を知らせ、書面でも意見を受け取る」, allowing preparation and written responses rather than insisting on immediate speech.
  3. Meaning: To compare how often people speak, everyone should be asked to speak the same number of times. In this question: Wrong — The goal is 「話す速さにかかわらず、考えを示せる場を作りたい。」, which concerns opportunities to communicate thoughts rather than equal speaking counts for comparison.
  4. Meaning: We should avoid judging them by how little they speak and enable them to communicate through advance preparation or writing as well. In this question: Correct — The change 「会議の前に論点を知らせ、書面でも意見を受け取るようにしている」 provides both preparation and written contributions, addressing the risk of judging motivation by limited speech.

Evidence: それ以来、私は会議の前に論点を知らせ、書面でも意見を受け取るようにしている。 話す速さにかかわらず、考えを示せる場を作りたい。

← All N2 reading passages