Learn · N2 · Short reading

無償でもらった品の感想

調理器具の感想を読んでいたら、最後に「商品はメーカーから無償で提供」とあった。知人は、ただでもらった人の評価は信用できないと言った。私は、無償提供だけで内容をすべて否定するのは早いと思う。有料で買った人にも好みの偏りはある。むしろ、どんな関係で試し、何を確かめたのかが分かることが大切だ。提供の事実を隠さず、使いにくかった点も具体的に示してこそ、読者は自分に役立つ情報かどうかを判断できる。
English study notes

Learning objective

Identify the writer’s conditions for evaluating free-product reviews.

Reading help

Receiving a product free from its manufacturer leads the acquaintance to distrust a review, but the writer rejects that automatic judgment. Paying does not remove personal preferences either; readers need disclosure of the relationship and concrete experience, including inconvenient features, to assess whether the information helps them.

Glossary

器具(きぐ)
Equipment for a particular task; here, the cooking tool supplied for review.
否定(ひてい)
Rejecting the truth or validity of something.
示してこそ
Only by giving concrete details, including difficulties, can the reviewer enable readers to judge the information’s usefulness.

After reading

- A reviewer disclosed that the manufacturer supplied the product for free. - Free provision alone does not justify dismissing the review. - Disclosure and concrete observations help readers assess its usefulness.

Exam focus & common mistakes

• A free sample is neither an automatic guarantee nor an automatic disqualification: 「無償提供だけで」 limits the rejection. • Hiding the free provision contradicts 「隠さず」 even when the review gives useful details about operation.

Exam practice and explanations

Exam practice

筆者は無償提供された商品の感想について、どう考えているか。

Show answer

Answer: 2

  1. Meaning: It is always more trustworthy than comments by people who paid for the product. In this question: Wrong — 「有料で買った人にも好みの偏りはある」 questions a simple division; it does not rank free products above paid ones.
  2. Meaning: If the fact of the provision and specific details of use are shown, it can serve as material for judgment. In this question: Correct — Readers can decide when the review discloses 「提供の事実」 and describes 「使いにくかった点も具体的に」.
  3. Meaning: Readers need not be told that the product was received free of charge. In this question: Wrong — Disclosure is necessary in 「提供の事実を隠さず」.
  4. Meaning: Since personal preferences are biased, comments by people who paid cannot be used either. In this question: Wrong — The conclusion enables judgment about 「自分に役立つ情報かどうか」 rather than discarding all reviews.

Evidence: 提供の事実を隠さず、使いにくかった点も具体的に示してこそ、読者は自分に役立つ情報かどうかを判断できる。

← All N2 reading passages