Learn · N2 · Short reading

投票用紙に名前を書かない理由

組合で新しい方針を決める際、投票用紙には名前を書かない。誰が反対したのか分からなければ、責任のある議論にならないという意見もある。しかし、私は逆だと思う。上司に知られる心配が残っていては、本音を示せない人がいるからだ。安心して意思を示せる仕組みを整えないことには、結果が組合員全体の考えを表しているとは言えない。名前を隠すのは無責任にするためではなく、一人一人の判断を守るためである。
English study notes

Learning objective

Separate the writer’s defense of anonymous voting from an opposing opinion.

Reading help

The writer argues that anonymous union ballots protect genuine individual choices. Fear that a superior could identify a dissenting vote may otherwise distort the result. The claim about needing names for responsibility is an opposing view, not the writer’s conclusion.

Glossary

本音(ほんね)
A person’s actual feelings or wishes, rather than a public stance.
組合(くみあい)
An organized association, here a union.
ないことには
Makes a safe way to express a choice a necessary condition for a representative result.

After reading

- Named ballots can discourage some members from expressing disagreement. - Anonymous voting is defended as a protection for individual judgment. - A concern about responsibility is presented before being challenged.

Exam focus & common mistakes

• Speaker attribution matters: 「という意見もある」 belongs to critics of anonymous voting. • Only after a safe voting arrangement exists can the outcome plausibly represent members’ views.

Exam practice and explanations

Exam practice

筆者は無記名の投票に、どのような意味があると考えているか。

Show answer

Answer: 4

  1. Meaning: It identifies opponents so they can be held responsible in discussion. In this question: Wrong — Identifying opponents belongs to the view introduced as 「という意見もある」, which the writer rejects.
  2. Meaning: It lets the union decide policy without members thinking carefully. In this question: Wrong — The protected element is 「判断」, so removing careful thought is not its purpose.
  3. Meaning: It shows everyone the superior’s opinion to make the result easier to consolidate. In this question: Wrong — The concern is members being exposed to superiors: 「上司に知られる心配」, not publication of a superior’s choice.
  4. Meaning: It reduces concern about others and allows each person to express a genuine choice. In this question: Correct — The purpose is 「一人一人の判断を守るため」, after explaining fear of a superior discovering the vote.

Evidence: 名前を隠すのは無責任にするためではなく、一人一人の判断を守るためである。

← All N2 reading passages